Hey All. Check out this website, www.spot.us. It’s a cutting edge journalism project that solicits news story ideas and small donations from community members. Once a substantial amount of funds are raised, a journalist investigates the story. Right now, its centered in the Bay Area in California. But it could easily be mimicked everywhere. Pretty amazing. Talk about a new paradigm in the journalism business.
The whole idea is kind of blowing my mind. It brings up a lot of questions about what journalism is, how it is done, and who the “product” is for. The creators of this website/project would object to my use of “product” because, as they say in the description of the project, “journalism is a process.” I find that sentence fascinating. I mean, I understand what it ostensibly means. But if it is a process and not a product, how does it fit in with market economics. This brings us back to those questions I just brought up.
If this post reads incoherently, I apologize. My brain is going a million miles a second on this stuff. But let me try to slow down.
So, this not academic, but off the top of my head, journalism is the act of investigating and reporting information for public awareness. I am sure that is a flawed definition, but to me it is journalism in its most pure form, i.e. without economic considerations. Society functions best when those components that make up society are well informed. (This is certainly questionable as well. Surely the ignorance that pervades our society, for all its deplorable aspects, allows agents of power to function without rebuke, hence maintaining some kind of stability. I am certainly not advocating for ignorance; its merely an observation.)
Back to what I was saying. So, hypothetically speaking, let’s say society functions best when its respective components are perfectly informed. The more perfectly informed we are about the world, the better decisions we would make to move forward. (Again, I see all kinds of objections in this argument even as a write it.)
Journalism, then, is the act of informing society. And, with the internet’s ability to drastically reduce costs of production and distribution of information, we have seen an explosion of journalistic acts by amateurs. (Note: read We Are All Journalists Now (a highly disturbing title for pros out there) by Scott Gant. It is not necessarily mind blowing, but it does a good job of discussing the transformation of journalism and many of the legal implications involved with expanding the definition of “legitimate news sources” to include bloggers.)
Now, to move to economic considerations, the news business has always functioned in a marketplace. News sources produce a product that will be consumed widely. While there are many implications to this, one that piques my interest is the way society reinforces its own ignorance. If we demanded thorough investigative reporting with in-depth analysis, that is what we would get. Instead, we demand Fox News, broadly speaking.
But spot.us actually turns this self fulfilling cycle of societal ignorance on its head by gauging demand through story idea contributions and financial contributions. To use an overused word at this point, the process seems organic. Its pay-per-view journalism. I’m not saying this is an ideal paradigm for the entire news business, but perhaps a variety of business plans would create more opportunities for good journalism.
There are a million little externalities, extrapolations and other contingencies that need to be addressed. But its certainly worth trying. Bravo spot.us!
Check it out and tell me what you think.